Together with Fania Mindell and Ethel Byrne, Margaret Sanger opened a birth control clinic in Brooklyn in 1916 in violation of contemporary laws banning birth control dissemination by non-physicians. Shortly after it opened, a policewoman, posing as a client, arrested Sanger and closed down the clinic. Here, Margaret Sanger is shown outside the courthouse after her arraignment in 1917.
Would you risk public censure and censorship to oppose a law that you considered to be wrong?
This pamphlet, produced by Sanger, teaches adolescent girls about "the beauty and wonder and sacredness of the sex functions." Must we judge censorship in the context of its day? Do you think Sanger overstepped her bounds by providing such information to young girls in the early 1900s?
In 1873, the Comstock Laws outlawed the mailing of "obscene," "lewd," "indecent," or "filthy" materials. These laws were named after Anthony Comstock, secretary of the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice, a society founded on "Morals, Not Art or Literature." In the above speech, given at Faneuil Hall in Boston in 1878, T. B. Wakeman argued against the Comstock Laws, claiming freedom of the press to be "the birthright secured to us in the Bill of Rights by Massachusetts and Patrick Henry and Thomas Jefferson." Nonetheless, despite the reaction against these statutes, the Comstock Laws remain on the books even today, although largely unenforced. Specifically, section 211 of the Comstock Laws outlaws the use of the U. S. Postal Service to send birth control materials.
Margaret Sanger's Woman Rebel (1914), a feminist newspaper advocating the use of birth control, was censored by the Post Office in accordance with the Comstock Laws.